The ultimate guide to a successful loyalty program
|
Post written by
In this article, we'll walk you through the various goals a loyalty program can support and the strategies you can use to reach them. We'll share simple tactics and real-world examples. By the end, you'll have a clear idea of how to design a loyalty program that maximizes your business's value.
The Challenges
In this piece, we cover the goals loyalty programs can support and the strategies behind them. We explain different tactics using relevant examples. After reading, you should have a better grasp of how to build a program that boosts your business value. Sometimes, the sheer number of features can feel overwhelming. Plus, with endless room for creativity, the possibilities are virtually limitless. But which features actually matter for your company? We need a strategic framework to guide our design and ensure the program delivers the business impact you want. § Background § Loyalty programs have a long history and continue to evolve in today’s business landscape. In this guide, we outline strategies to design effective programs that maximize value. We dive into the goals loyalty programs can support and offer simple tactics to achieve them. By understanding the core features and frameworks, companies can build loyalty programs tailored to their unique needs and customers.
The Solution
Loyalty programs have been around for over 70 years. One of the most famous examples is American Airlines' program, launched in the 1980s. They were among the first to reward frequent flyers, letting them earn miles for free flights or seat upgrades, and introducing bronze, silver, or gold tiers.
Another key milestone was UK supermarket giant Tesco's "Clubcard" in the 1990s. It was the first program to use data for true 1-to-1 personalization, paving the way for Tesco's golden years.
A few years ago, Sephora launched its Beauty Insider program. Beyond a basic "earn & burn" model, it connected members with an online community and digital features like skin-tone analysis, reviews, and more. There are countless ways to design a program and many popular features to choose from. But the real question is: which ones are right for your business?
Too often, loyalty program design is handed over to a creative agency just to make a "unique" program with a wow factor to beat the competition. What is often missing is a strategic plan of which business goals the program should support and which features actually drive those goals.
First step - define your business goals
Even though the term "loyalty program" suggests the main goal is simply to build loyalty—which was true for the very first programs—modern programs often have other goals. These include collecting customer data or even acting as a profit center for the business.
Plus, "loyalty" itself needs to be defined.
Loyalty-driven programs
Loyalty is complex. It means different things to different people and is usually split into emotional and behavioral loyalty.
The emotional side is what most people think of—faithfulness, devotion, and alignment with a brand. In business, emotional loyalty is often measured by engagement, customer satisfaction, and brand affinity. While the hope is that emotional connection eventually leads to buying behavior, these programs focus directly on building that deeper bond.
The loyalty matrix defines how your business drives keeping customers. Emotionally driven programs aim to improve brand perception, boost engagement, or elevate the customer experience.
Behavioral programs, on the other hand, focus directly on customer actions. In some cases, they aim to make it harder or less appealing for customers to switch to a competitor.
In marketing terms, behavioral loyalty is measured by shopping frequency, share of wallet, average basket size, the variety of categories bought, and so on. Some programs focus strictly on driving these actions, nothing more.
Data-driven programs
Some programs exist solely to collect customer data. As data and personalization become more crucial, businesses need a way to link purchases to specific shoppers and get consent to use that info. The more sales tracked through the program, the richer the insights, leading to better personalization.
Programs as a standalone business
Some loyalty programs, or parts of them, operate as profit centers. For example, airline programs earn kickbacks from banks for co-branded credit cards, or retail partner programs where other brands pay to issue points. Selling data to third parties is another revenue stream. For some companies, these setups are surprisingly profitable.
Three key strategies for emotional loyalty programs
To build emotional loyalty, you need features that deepen your relationship with customers.
For emotional programs, there are three main paths:
Emotional connection for high-value customers
Elevating customer experiences
Boosting brand perception
Programs focused on emotional connections for high-value customers work best when most of your revenue comes from a small, core group of shoppers. Growing and retaining this group is a top priority. You see this in airlines, where business travelers make up most of the profit. These systems usually feature tiers (gold, silver, bronze) where VIPs get special treatment and status-boosting perks. Presentation is key here—much like how a gift wrap shapes the perception of the gift inside. This strategy requires high margins per customer to fund the often-expensive perks.
Programs focused on customer experience gatekeep special services so only member have access. These can be physical or digital. Sephora’s program links to an online community, giving members digital perks like personalized skin-color analysis, product reviews, custom recommendations, and inspiring content.
Programs that boost brand perception focus on highlighting core brand values
This usually involves storytelling around a specific program feature. For example, when Swedish insurer Folksam designed its program, it focused on its customer-owned, mutual structure. They used a classic payout model, communicating that members received benefits simply because they own the company. The North Face is another great example. Their program gives members access to outdoor events like climbing or skiing and chats with professional athletes, positioning the brand as a true partner in outdoor adventure.
Two main strategies for behavioral programs
If your main goal is to drive specific customer actions, you have two options: target all customers generally, or try to lock in your highest-value shoppers.
Basic "earn & burn" is the classic behavioral tactic.
Other tactics include progressive bonus scales (the more you buy, the higher the % back), gamification, extra points for engagement (like downloading the app, logging in, sharing contact details, recruiting friends, or reusing bags), points promo periods, and bonuses for co-branded cards or partners.
Today, personalized and trigger-based messages are essential for any earn & burn program. Customer interest is naturally low; on average, consumers belong to 2-8 programs but forget most of them. Personalized messages are key to triggering actions or simply reminding them the program exists. These basic models are the most common in retail and grocery stores.
Both Coop [1] and Stadium [2] use progressive tier structures where your bonus percentage increases the more you spend.
Lock-in tactics are the second behavioral strategy
Though this approach has been around for decades, it is growing fast. The modern wave started with Amazon Prime, offering members free shipping and other perks for an annual fee. This model has since spread from e-commerce to traditional retailers and grocery chains.
Tesco offers Clubcard members 10% off their purchases for a monthly subscription of £7.99.
A more traditional lock-in example is membership-only warehouse stores requiring an annual fee to shop. Cingular Society charges a yearly fee to let shoppers buy items close to wholesale prices.
Since customer loyalty is decreasing across industries, we will likely see more lock-in programs soon. This strategy works best for products bought frequently.
Three ways to collect customer data through a program
There are three common approaches for programs whose main goal is data collection:
Basic bonus systems
Discount- or service-based models
Personalization-based plans
The shared goal is to gather customer data at the lowest possible cost.
The most common tactic is a basic bonus, like points, stamp cards, or cash back. Keep the bonus as low as possible while still driving sign-ups, and avoid extra features to keep costs down. If this is your strategy, stick to the basics.
The discount- or service-based model focuses on giving members discounts or simple services that are cheap to provide. This could be member-only discounts on top sellers or simple digital perks like paperless receipts and handy guides.
IKEA Family is a classic example. Membership offers free coffee, free paper bags, and discounts on everyday items like fire extinguishers or alarms, helping IKEA cover 80-90% of sales through the program. Recently, IKEA added "earn & burn" features, letting members redeem points for various products and services.
Keep the net costs of benefits as low as possible, including discounts and IT costs. Since these programs don't require points management, IT overhead is often lower than in basic bonus systems.
Home improvement chain Lowe’s uses a program that offers members access to handy business services.
The personalization approach pitching custom experiences as a benefit valuable enough for customers to join. It drops earn & burn features entirely. Swedish examples include Akademibokhandeln and Clas Ohlson. Swedish grocer ICA tried this model, but after a drop in tracked sales, they returned to a basic earn & burn program. So far, brands have struggled with this model because customers don't always see the immediate value. To succeed long-term, this strategy demands top-tier 1-to-1 personalization, including product tips, curated content, personal discounts, and helpful digital services.
Hybrid programs and finding the right mix
In reality, most loyalty programs use a mix of these strategies. This isn't always intentional; programs often naturally collect more features and tactics over time.
However, having multiple goals is completely fine, meaning a hybrid approach can work wonders. The trick is finding the right balance for your specific business situation and goals. Depending on your industry, some strategies will naturally fit better than others.
The golden rule is to start with your business goals and evaluate every strategy and tactic against them.
When designing a loyalty program, remember to:
Tailor your strategy: Match your program to your specific industry and business model. A custom approach ensures your program fits your customers' unique lifestyles and needs.
Use data to decide: Back up your decisions with real customer insights. Track behavior and preferences to make the program more personal and effective.
Evolve over time: Loyalty programs aren't static; they grow. Regularly review performance and adapt to changing customer expectations and market shifts to keep your program fresh and valuable.
By keeping these points in mind and staying focused on clear goals, you can build a successful, well-rounded loyalty program that delivers real business value.
